Makelab vs Protolabs for plastic 3D printing and large parts
Makelab is a 3D printing factory in Brooklyn running FDM, SLA, Industrial SLA, MJF and FGF. You get an instant quote, plastic parts in one piece far bigger than Protolabs' largest SLA build, and the engineers who run your job. Protolabs is a large manufacturer based in Minnesota, with factories in the US, the UK and Germany, that also molds, machines and prints metal.
Makelab and Protolabs side by side
Makelab
Protolabs
What you get from Makelab
An instant quote that checks your file
- Upload a CAD file and see the price and every lead-time option in seconds.
- The instant quote checks wall thickness and part size as you upload, and an engineer reviews every file before it prints.
Five processes, large parts included
- FDM, SLA, Industrial SLA, MJF and FGF, in 21 materials.
- One-piece parts up to 94 x 94 x 39 in (2400 × 2400 × 1000 mm) on FGF and 67 x 31 x 24 in (1700 × 800 × 600 mm) on Industrial SLA.
The engineers who run your job answer you
- Questions about orientation, splits or material go to the people printing the part.
- Our design engineers repair files, rebuild parts from scans and redesign them for printing.
Pickup in Brooklyn, next-day delivery in NYC
- Pickup at our Sunset Park factory is free, and delivery across NYC and northern New Jersey is next day.
- We ship to all 50 states.
Prices you can see before you order
- The instant quote gives the price before you order. There is no minimum order, and bulk discounts start at 10 parts.
- Our cost estimator shows price ranges from shipped orders.
One part or a production run
- We ship 5,000+ parts a week. A single prototype gets the same file review and inspection as a production order.
- Certificates of conformity, material data sheets and inspection reports on production orders.
Our recommendation
When another option fits
Choose Protolabs when
- You need injection molding, or a printed prototype is heading for molded production at volume.
- You need CNC machining, sheet metal or metal 3D printing.
- Your program requires AS9100, ISO 13485 or ITAR registration on file.
- You are in Europe. Protolabs has factories in the UK and Germany.
Parts we 3D print, by material and process
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Does Protolabs make its own parts?
Protolabs runs its own factories in Minnesota, North Carolina, New Hampshire, the UK and Germany. It also pairs them with Protolabs Network (formerly Hubs), which sends work to partner manufacturers, and it lists FDM printing as a Protolabs Network service. Makelab prints most parts on its own floor in Brooklyn, FDM included.
What is the largest part Protolabs can 3D print compared to Makelab?
Protolabs lists 29 x 25 x 21 in (736 x 635 x 533 mm) as its largest SLA build, in ABS-like resins. Makelab's Industrial SLA prints up to 1700 × 800 × 600 mm, and our FGF large-format printers go up to 2400 × 2400 × 1000 mm. Bigger parts can be printed in sections and assembled.
Is Protolabs faster than Makelab?
Protolabs advertises 3D printed parts in as fast as one day. Makelab lead times run FDM from 1 business day, SLA from 2 business days, MJF from 5 business days, Industrial SLA from 7 business days, FGF from 7 business days, and the instant quote shows every lead-time option for your part. In New York, pickup in Brooklyn is free and local delivery is next day.
Does Makelab do injection molding like Protolabs?
No, we only 3D print. Above about 5,000 identical parts, a molder such as Protolabs is hard to beat. Below roughly 2,000, MJF nylon usually costs less than paying for a mold, and our injection molding vs 3D printing comparison walks through the numbers.
Is there a 3D printing service in New York that makes parts in-house?
Yes. Makelab is a 3D printing factory in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, running FDM, SLA, Industrial SLA, MJF and FGF, and most parts are printed on our own floor. Pickup is free, and we deliver next day across NYC and northern New Jersey. Upload a file at quote.makelab.com for an instant price.
More comparisons
MJF
Injection molding vs 3D printing — which one is right for your volume?
MJF
CNC machining vs 3D printing — subtractive vs additive.
SLA vs FDM
Resin vs filament 3D printing — SLA vs FDM for real-world parts.
MJF
SLS vs MJF — two powder-bed nylon processes, different trade-offs.
FDM
FDM vs CNC — when to print plastic, when to mill it.
MJF
MJF vs urethane casting — two paths to low-volume production.
FDM
3D printing for prototyping vs production — how the choices change.
FDM
PLA vs ABS — the two classic FDM filaments compared.
FDM
PETG vs ASA — indoor workhorse vs outdoor champion.
MJF
Nylon PA12 vs aluminum — when printed nylon replaces machined metal.
FDM vs SLA
FDM vs SLA — which 3D printing technology is right for your part?
FDM vs MJF
FDM vs MJF — cost-effective prototyping vs production-grade nylon.
SLA vs MJF
SLA vs MJF — precision and finish vs production-grade strength.
FDM vs Industrial SLA
FDM vs Industrial SLA — two paths to large-format 3D printing.
MJF
MJF vs injection molding — when does 3D printing make more sense?
FDM vs SLA vs MJF
FDM vs SLA vs MJF — the complete 3D printing technology comparison.
FDM
PLA vs PETG — choosing the right FDM material.
MJF
Nylon PA12 vs PA11 — choosing the right MJF production material.
Makelab vs Xometry vs Protolabs vs Craftcloud
Xometry vs Protolabs vs Craftcloud vs Makelab: which to choose for 3D printing
Makelab vs Xometry
Makelab vs Xometry for plastic 3D printing: one factory or 5,000 suppliers
Makelab vs Craftcloud
Makelab vs Craftcloud: one US factory or 150+ partner shops
Xometry alternatives
Xometry alternatives: Makelab for plastic 3D printing, and five more by process
3D printing services in NYC
3D printing services in New York City: how to choose for business parts
Related Resources
Keep exploring
Related Services
Large Format 3D Printing Service
Parts up to 2400mm on FGF and 1700mm on Industrial SLA. Architectural models, trade show props, full-scale prototypes.
MJF 3D Printing Service
HP Multi Jet Fusion 3D printing in Nylon PA12, PA11, and PA12 Glass Filled. Batch-consistent production parts in 5–7 business days.
Injection Molding Alternative
Skip the $30K-$100K tooling investment. Production-grade FDM, SLA, and MJF parts with zero mold cost and 3–5 day lead times.
Design Engineering
DfAM optimization, reverse engineering, geometry tuning.
Related Comparisons
Xometry vs Protolabs vs Craftcloud vs Makelab: which to choose for 3D printing
For plastic 3D printing in the US, choose Makelab. Parts print in one piece up to 94 x 94 x 39 in (2400 × 2400 × 1000 mm) on FGF, bigger than the limits Xometry and Protolabs list. The instant quote checks wall thickness and part size as you upload, and an engineer reviews every file before it prints. Most parts are printed and inspected on our own floor in Brooklyn, and you talk to the engineers running your job. There is no minimum order, and bulk discounts start at 10 parts. In New York and northern New Jersey, pickup is free and delivery is next day.
Makelab vs Xometry for plastic 3D printing: one factory or 5,000 suppliers
For plastic 3D printing, choose Makelab. The instant quote checks wall thickness and part size as you upload, and an engineer reviews every file before it prints. Most parts are printed and inspected on our own floor in Brooklyn, so the people answering your questions are the people running the job. Parts print in one piece up to 94 x 94 x 39 in (2400 × 2400 × 1000 mm) on FGF, past Xometry's 24 x 36 x 36 in limit without splitting. If the file needs work first, our design engineers repair it, rebuild it from a scan or redesign it for printing. In New York and northern New Jersey, pickup is free and delivery is next day.
Injection molding vs 3D printing — which one is right for your volume?
Choose 3D printing when volume is under 2,000–5,000 parts, lead time matters, design is still evolving, or geometry is too complex for mold tooling. Choose injection molding when volume exceeds 5,000+ of the same frozen design and tooling can be amortized over the run.
Xometry alternatives: Makelab for plastic 3D printing, and five more by process
For plastic 3D printing, Makelab is the Xometry alternative we recommend. You keep the instant quote, and it checks wall thickness and part size as you upload. Most parts are printed on our own floor in Brooklyn, so the engineers you talk to are the ones running your job. FDM, SLA, Industrial SLA, MJF and FGF cover prototypes through production, with one-piece parts up to 94 x 94 x 39 in (2400 × 2400 × 1000 mm). There is no minimum order, and bulk discounts start at 10 parts. In New York and northern New Jersey, pickup is free and delivery is next day.
Related Technologies
Industrial SLA
Industrial SLA 3D printing for large-format parts up to 1700 x 800 x 600mm. Presentation-quality surfaces at 5 Ra μm. Architecture models, props, and oversized prototypes.
FGF
FGF 3D printing service — largest build envelope in our facility at 2400 x 2400 x 1000mm. Pellet-fed extrusion for oversized structural parts and props.
MJF
MJF 3D printing service — production-grade Nylon PA12, PA11, and PA12 Glass Filled with batch consistency. Isotropic strength, no supports, lead times from 5 business days. Brooklyn, NY.
Ready to start production?
Upload your CAD file and get a quote in minutes — or talk to our engineers about your next production run.